Local faces. More choices. Clear answers.
Insurance starts with people who listen.
From home and auto to business and life, the Butler family team helps you understand your options. As an independent agency, they can compare coverage from more than 20 insurance companies.
Rather sit down and talk? Butler’s online form also lets you choose Appointment Request.
Previously with Attar Insurance? Butler welcomed Attar clients to its Fishers office in 2025.
Read the agency introduction ↗What can we help protect?
Coverage for real life.
Find the right starting point, then talk through the details with a local team. These links lead to Butler’s current coverage pages.
Auto insurance
Cars, new drivers, and the coverage choices that matter when plans change.
Explore auto coverage ↗02 / AT HOMEHome insurance
Help protecting where you live, what is inside, and your financial footing.
Explore home coverage ↗03 / AT WORKBusiness insurance
Talk through risks tied to the business you have worked hard to build.
Explore business coverage ↗04 / FOR THE FUTURELife insurance
Consider how to care for the people who depend on you.
Explore life coverage ↗Why an independent family agency?
One conversation. More than one company to consider.
Todd began his insurance career in 1992 with one insurer. He later became independent so he could offer customers more choices. Today, he works alongside Ieva and his son Drew to serve clients from their Fishers office.
- ✓Compare options across represented companies, according to your needs.
- ✓Ask a real person what a policy does, what it costs, and what changes when life does.
- ✓Call the office for help when a claim or coverage question comes up.
Real photo from Butler’s customer service page. This concept has not been approved by the agency.A straightforward next step
Start in the way that works for you.
Tell them what changed
A home purchase, new driver, growing business, or simply a question about your current policy.
Review your options
The Butler team can look across the companies it represents and discuss coverage, price, and fit.
Know who to call later
The agency says its team helps clients with coverage questions and through the claims process.
Trust is earned over time
Real customers. Real experience.
Before choosing an insurance agency, see what other clients say about how the team explains coverage, answers questions, and helps when something goes wrong.
Review score is a dated snapshot of Butler’s own site; check the live page for the latest rating and count.
Already insured with Butler?
Need help with a claim or your policy?
You do not need to start a new quote. Visit Butler’s existing customer service page for billing and claims information, or call the office directly.
Find your people
A real office. A real number to call.
Butler Insurance serves the greater Indianapolis area from Fishers and says it can write insurance in 29 other states.
Fishers, IN 46038
Saturday and evening appointments available; call to arrange.
Photo of Butler’s Fishers office from its website.